(CNN) A Colorado father is petitioning to make the
sale of smartphones for children under 13 illegal in his state after witnessing
his young sons' addictive behaviors toward the technology.
"One of my sons, I took it away, and it was a pretty
dramatic, very violent outburst," said Dr. Timothy J. Farnum, a father of
five who is an anesthesiologist by training. "He was very addicted to this
little machine. It kind of scared me, and that's really how it started."
Farnum said he was disturbed by his 10- and 11-year-olds' loss
of interest in activities such as playing outside, as well as research on the
potentially harmful impacts of excessive technology use.
In February, he and some medical colleagues started an
organization called Parents Against Underage Smartphones. They started a ballot
initiative in March aimed at prohibiting smartphone sales to anyone under the age
of 13 or someone intending to give the device to a person under that age.
Their petition needs about 150,000 signatures. It will require retailers to ask a customer their age or the age
of the intended primary owner of the smartphone before the sale, according to
the initial fiscal impact statement.
Retailers will also have to file a monthly
report to the state Department of Revenue that lists whether the type of phone
sold was a smartphone or a cellular phone and how old the owner was at the time
of the purchase, according to the statement. The Department of Revenue will
then create a portal to investigate these reports and collect any fees and
penalties from the retailer. The first violation will result in a written
warning, the second violation will carry a $500 fine, and the fine will double
for each subsequent violation.
"You know, to most of the people that
are saying things like, 'Well, it's a parent's right; how dare the government
do this,' I would like to say, I'm not the government, I'm a parent. And we, parents, need to decide what is best for our kids," Farnum said. "And
we can't do it alone."
When asked about the proposed age
restriction, CTIA, a trade group that represents the wireless technology
industry, said in a statement, "mobile phones can empower kids to learn,
engage and communicate with family, teachers and friends, and we encourage
parents to talk with their children about responsible use and set rules that
are right for their family. The wireless industry provides a number of tools to
help parents make informed choices and manage their children's usage."
Dr. Donald Shifrin, a clinical professor of
pediatrics at the University of Washington School of Medicine and spokesman for
the American Academy of Pediatrics, said he is skeptical that legislation will
lead to an improved management of smartphone use in children. Parents should be
responsible for creating rules and expectations about using the phone, he said.
"When youngsters leave our house to go somewhere, as
parents, we often say, 'Where are you going? What are you going to do?
Who are you going to be with, and when will you be back?' And sometimes, we
forget to use that terminology when they're online," Shifrin said.
"Those parameters stay the same regardless of what kind of media those
youngsters are using, whether it's tablets, computers, laptops or cell
phones."
Studies have shown the impact these devices can have on
children. In fact, a study published in May found that children between the ages of 6 months and 2 years had
a 49% increased risk of expressive speech delay per 30-minute increase in daily
screen time. Last year, a poll revealed that 50% of teenagers
think they are addicted to their own smartphones.
There are no evidence-based age recommendations for when a child
should get their first phone, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics.
A common rule of thumb is around seventh to eighth grade, Shifrin said. But it
is essential for parents to set guidelines regarding how and when the phone
should be used.
Holland Haiis, a digital detox and connectivity expert, is also
not fond of Farnum's proposed legislation.
"What it seems like is happening here is that instead of
the dog wagging the tail, it looks like the tail is wagging the dog," she
said. "Because it's not necessarily the store or the provider's
responsibility to have laws implemented for how you should take care of your
child at a consumer level like this. It really starts at home."
You can also watch the video by clicking on the Play Button
